Can employees refuse to work together: Understanding employers’ options

Relationships in the workplace are not always straightforward. Personalities can clash, and disagreements can happen, which can lead to uncomfortable situations even between the closest-knit teams.

As an employer, do you know what to do when employees say that they will no longer work together?

While employers can see this as a petty argument, they should be careful not to dismiss concerns without investigation, as in some circumstances, a refusal to work with a colleague can highlight some wider concerns that require action.

Can an employee refuse to work with a colleague?

Generally, employees have an expectation to work with their colleagues as a part of their contractual obligations.

Whether the conflict is a simple personality clash or an explosive argument in the office, it is an unlikely justification for employees refusing to work with one another.

If employees refuse to work together, it may be cause for disciplinary action if they unreasonably refuse to carry out their role.

However, employers should first take a holistic approach to understand the root cause of the refusal to work together before disciplinary action is pursued.

When might a refusal be justified?

Disagreements between colleagues are often just a difference in personalities. However, if claims of bullying, harassment or intimidation arise, employers must take this seriously.

This is because, under the Equality Act 2010, harassment in relation to protected characteristics such as age, disability, race, religion, sex or sexual orientation can expose employers to legal action.

There is also consideration surrounding discrimination if an employee refuses to work with someone because they are experiencing discrimination. Employers should investigate promptly.

Additionally, if an employee feels as if there is an imminent threat to their safety, whether that is threats, aggressive behaviour or safeguarding concerns, employees are granted certain protections.

What should employers do?

Before employers make any assumptions about the situation, they should first investigate the matter.

This could be by meeting with the employee, understanding the reasons behind the refusal and then reviewing any available evidence.

Once employers have all the facts, they should then follow their workplace procedures. This could be taking a look at grievance procedures or bullying and harassment policies.

While you are managing the issue, it may be beneficial for you to separate employees temporarily, alter shifts or allow remote working arrangements where possible.

These measures can help to reduce conflict while official investigations take place.

Supporting employers in tough times

A refusal to work with a colleague should never be viewed in isolation. While employees cannot usually decide who they work with, employers should examine the reasons behind any refusal before taking action.

Our team can support you when you are dealing with disputes between employees to help you resolve workplace conflicts while minimising legal risks.

For support with disputes between employees, get in touch with our team.

LinkedIn
Share
FbMessenger
URL has been copied successfully!

Contact us

Complete the below form and a member of our team will get back to you

If you would like to see full details of our data practices please visit our Privacy Policy and if you have any questions please email dataprotection@hethertons.co.uk.

Our office will close at 12pm on Thursday 24th December 2026 and reopen at 9am on Monday 4th January 2027